The Proposition
Public discussion on this topic often relies on opinion, speculation, videos, photographs, social media posts, or anecdotal accounts. This challenge takes a different approach. Rather than debating beliefs, it asks a simple question:
Can the claim be demonstrated using evidence that can be independently verified?
A prize of AUD $10,000 will be awarded to the first entrant who successfully demonstrates the claim in accordance with the published competition rules and evidence requirements.
The challenge is open to anyone. You do not need to be a scientist or academic to participate. However, any evidence submitted must be capable of independent verification and must satisfy the published assessment criteria.
The competition is designed to be fair, transparent, and impartial. The outcome is not predetermined. If a participant provides evidence that meets the required standard, the prize will be awarded. If no submission meets that standard, no prize will be awarded.
What This Challenge Is About
This challenge is not intended to ridicule or dismiss anyone’s views, nor is it intended to promote any particular belief.
Its purpose is to encourage evidence-based discussion by providing a clear framework for evaluating claims. Participants are invited to present the strongest case they can, using reliable and verifiable evidence rather than speculation or opinion.
The competition will be judged solely on the quality and strength of the evidence submitted.
Evidence Matters
Not all information carries the same evidential weight.
Many claims circulating online rely on material that cannot be independently verified or reproduced. This challenge requires evidence that can be examined, authenticated, and evaluated objectively.
Detailed evidence requirements are published separately and explain exactly what forms of evidence are acceptable, what supporting documentation is required, and what types of material are insufficient on their own.
Independent Assessment
All submissions will be assessed against the published rules and evidence standards.
The assessment process is intended to be transparent and consistent. Every entrant will be judged using the same criteria, regardless of their personal views or conclusions.
Information about the judging process, adjudicators, and assessment methodology will be published before the competition opens.
The Prize
The successful entrant will receive AUD $10,000.
The full amount of the prize will be placed under the control of an independent third party. The prize money will remain reserved exclusively for this competition until it is either awarded to a successful entrant or the competition closes in accordance with the published rules.
The purpose of this arrangement is to ensure participants can enter with confidence, knowing that the prize funds have been set aside and will be available for payment immediately if a submission is judged to have met the published evidence standard.
Before You Enter
Before preparing a submission, participants should carefully read the Competition Rules, Evidence Requirements, and Frequently Asked Questions. These documents explain how submissions will be assessed and the standards that must be met before the prize can be awarded.
The objective is straightforward: if compelling, independently verifiable evidence exists, this challenge provides an opportunity to present it.
